Skip to content

How to Value Growth and Unprofitable Companies

By Alexander Chepakovich · Updated

Why this is a hard problem

Most valuation machinery was built for mature, profitable businesses: earnings exist, cash flow is positive, and the future looks roughly like the recent past. Growth companies violate every part of that. Their earnings may be negative by design — they are spending heavily to build scale — and their value lies almost entirely in a future that has not happened yet. Valuing them means valuing a forecast, with all the humility that requires.

The market's usual workaround is comparative valuation: price-to-sales multiples against similar companies. But because the method is non-fundamental — it does not rely on any intrinsic characteristic of the company itself — it can produce wild excesses. When every company in a sector is priced off every other company, the whole group can detach from value together.

Where conventional DCF breaks

Standard discounted cash flow work projects future net cash flows as a fixed proportion of revenue — a stable margin assumption. For a well-established firm in a mature industry that is reasonable. For a start-up or fast-growing company it is hardly applicable: currently negative cash flow, extrapolated at a fixed margin, gives a permanently worthless business — even when the losses are the cost of building something that will soon generate plenty.

The deeper issue is that the fixed-margin assumption cannot express what growth companies actually do: margins expand as revenue scales, because some costs do not grow with the top line. A model that cannot see operating leverage will systematically misvalue any company whose economics are still forming.

Separating fixed and variable costs

The repair is to stop projecting margins and start projecting cost structure. Total expenses split into two parts: variable costs, which rise in proportion to revenue, and fixed costs, which do not. Once you know that split, a revenue growth forecast translates into a profitability forecast mechanically — as revenue grows faster than the fixed-cost base, the margin expands on its own. The model derives profitability instead of assuming it.

Hypothetical example. A company has $200m revenue, $150m variable costs and $90m fixed costs — a $40m loss. Double the revenue: variable costs double to $300m but fixed costs stay near $90m — now it earns $10m. Nothing was assumed about margins; the improvement followed from the cost split. Loss-makers can be valued this way on fundamentals, not sentiment.

Growth must decay

Whatever rate you forecast, it cannot last forever — no company outgrows the economy it lives in indefinitely. A defensible long-run assumption decays the revenue growth rate toward a mature level over time. The Chepakovich model, the basis of InvestorsCraft's intrinsic value estimates, argues that terminal level should equal GDP growth and decays projected growth toward it.

This one choice dominates the answer for growth companies, because most of their value sits in distant years. A 20% growth rate held for thirty years produces a company larger than the global economy; the same rate decayed to GDP-level over a decade produces something that could actually exist.

The Chepakovich model approach

The Chepakovich valuation model was built precisely for this problem. Its distinguishing feature is an original method for splitting total expenses into fixed and variable expenses from income-statement data — which, combined with projected revenue growth rates, makes forecasting future profitability possible even for companies that are currently unprofitable.

For intrinsic value estimation it does not require the company to pay dividends or even to have positive net income; all that is needed is several years of financial statements and an estimate of future revenue growth. That makes fundamental valuation — rather than comparative guesswork — possible for exactly the companies where it was previously impossible.

Practical rules for the investor

Demand a wider margin of safety. Every input for a growth or loss-making company is more uncertain, so the required discount of price to value should be wider than for a mature business.

Check the cash runway. A loss-making company's balance sheet matters as much as its story — how long can it fund itself before it must raise capital on the market's terms?

Be skeptical of multiples. For companies without earnings, the non-fundamental nature of comparative valuation makes it a sentiment gauge at best — exactly the failure mode the method exists to avoid.

Prefer models that derive profitability. A valuation that shows why and when margins improve is auditable; one that assumes them is a hope with formatting.

Try it

See it on real stocks

Frequently asked questions

Can a loss-making company have a positive intrinsic value?

Yes — losses are not the same as worthlessness. A company burning cash to build a profitable operation can be worth a great deal. The honest question is not 'is it profitable now?' but 'what do the economics look like when it matures, and how likely is that path?'.

Why does standard DCF fail for growth companies?

Conventional DCF projects cash flow as a fixed proportion of revenue — reasonable for a mature firm, meaningless for a company whose margins are still forming. A fixed-margin projection hardcodes today's losses or today's peak into the future.

Are multiples any better for unprofitable companies?

Multiples are worse — they are relative measures with no denominator when earnings are negative. Price-to-sales comparisons of unprofitable companies are essentially sentiment gauges, and they have produced wild market excesses.

This guide is educational content, not investment advice. Worked examples use hypothetical numbers unless labelled otherwise.